In this recurring feature, we take our first glimpse at shows which have been airing for several seasons. It may be one of your long-time favorites… but it’s new to us!


Episode: “Echoes”, airing Friday, April 20 on the Sci Fi Channel

Series overview: The STARGATE spin-off focuses on a group of scientists residing in and studying the culture of the lost city of Atlantis, which it turns out is in another galaxy.

Their take: The Sci-Fi Channel’s listing reads as such: Atlantis becomes a ghost town when spirits try to warn Teyla of an impending disaster.

Our take: A ghostly woman in white and a kinda creepy-looking burned guy – both of whom are spirits – begin appearing to several Atlantis residents while a scientist (bumbling and geeky in the manner of all B-movie/series characters) investigates the sudden arrival of several whale-like creatures. It takes the Atlantians a whole lot longer than us to figure out that the two phenomenon are connected. There’s much talk – often in bad accents – of “ancients” and the pre-requisite cocky pilot does more than his share of eye-rolling and hammy acting. Midway through the episode, a spaceship – piloted by THE X-FILES alum Mitch Pileggi – suddenly appears, apparently wanting to dock. With almost no explanation as to how (aside from an odd reference to the Macarena… we kid you not) the various Stargaters figure out what’s going on. Can they save the day? What do you think?

Accessibility: You won’t remember the character’s names or have much of a clue how they’re connected – if at all – to one another, but the cast is generally appealing and the story relatively self-contained. You’ll find recognizable elements of every sci-fi show from STAR TREK (the good guys use a transporter and even talk about being “beamed up”) to FARSCAPE (it’s hard not to see Joe Flanigan’s Sheppard as a knock-off of Ben Browder’s Crichton). And maybe it’s that very sense of familiarity that makes it so easy to dive into this rather cartoonish but inexplicably entertaining series. A first-time viewer will be a tad confused by mention of Ancients and Wraths, but find the episode fairly easy to follow. Despite being science fiction, it ain’t rocket science. When the closing credits roll, heck, you just might be compelled to come back next week.

For all the latest TV news and reviews

  • anonymouse

    And by “bad accents” you presumably mean Canadian accents, eh?

  • Gemnoire

    They got rid of one of the worst accent in season 1, bless Dr Grodin, he was a sweet boy but couldn’t do an english accent to save his life. As opposed to Dr Beckett’s glaswegian, which only slipped a couple of times I’ve been able to tell.

    Of course by “bad accents” he could be referring the generic Pegasus Galaxy human/Ancient accent… though actually, isn’t that usually Canadian?

  • Alan Rybak

    I love Stargate Atlantis, far superior to SG1. Great stuff, bring it on! Better than Star Trek, with a descent advesory (the Wraith) as compared to a Klingon! The Klingons aren’t scary at all, whereas the Wraith?? I give it 9/10 if they improve on off world planets & leave the actors from SG1 out of it! May it continue for a long time.