AMERICAN IDOL Season 8 Results: Who Went Home

Dying to know which contestant America sent home packing tonight, but not enough to actually sit through the commercial-filled, over-produced, hour-long borefest that was tonight’s AMERICAN IDOL results show? No problem, that’s what is here for!

Nobody! For the first time in AMERICAN IDOL history, the judges saved Matt Giraud from elimination. Good decision? Bad one? Shocked? Dismayed? Share your reaction below.

  • Irish Joe

    Bad decision by the judges… they should have let Matt go….

    Matt and either Alison, Anoop or Lil next wek so….?

    It’s disco week, so I feel that Lil will maybe perform a bit better than Alison with that genre… and Matt/Anoop are always so hit & miss that it could be either of those….

  • Billyjazz

    It was the right decision. Lil deserved to go. Matt should be fifth in the
    competition. Your final four are Adam, Danny, Kris, and Allison.

  • Younowho

    Judges just did it for the drama as they only had one more week to use that option. Problem is that someone who is actually good could need it next week and the option has been used. They are banking on the same bottom three!

  • Josh Emerson

    Awesome decision. I love Matt. He’s been my favorite all season.

    I would kill to see Adam or Danny gone next week, but unfortunately that’s not very likely. I know one or two of my four are gonna go (Matt/Allison/Anoop/Kris)

  • Gabi

    I adore Adam. He is so f-ing amazing I can’t stop listening to his music and watch his AI performances over and over. But now that they’vr saved Matt I am worried that one of the good ones, Adam, Kris or Allison might be eliminated next week and then there is no more save. I mean, people can forget to vote. That would really be bad. Even though I liked seeing everyone so happy when he got saved!

    But I am wondering what they were thinking, I mean, they said in the beginning of the season that the Save would be used on someone w/ the potential of winning the whole thing, and they clearly said Matt had no such chance. He’s not J.Hud or Daughtry so what’s the point?

    TV Addict – Who do you like on American Idol this year?

  • randa

    I wish they would have saved Megan 2 weeks ago. She should have been at least top 5. I loved her.