Top Stories

I would say Locke – if he is truly dead. One of my favourite characters and it really broke my heart with the plot twist in the season ending.

Other then that I’d say Shannon because she was pretty to look at. (Yes, shallow, I know. )

Without a doubt Leslie Artz!

Hurley: “You have some…Arntz…on you.”

Mr. Eko!

I would save Rousseau… I felt her ending was the most tragic (and a result of reasons outside of the show). Ditto for Mr. Eko.

I would save Shannon. I really hated her at first, but after Boone died, and she became involved with Sayid, I really liked the two of them together, and I was SO SAD for Sayid that he had to lose another love.

I have to third Mr Eko. He was such a great and in depth character that would have been great to have around more.

NO question — Charlie.

Def Charlie or Juliet I would just be happy to see the two people who honestly sacrificed themselves for the other losties to be safe or get out. Another go around for them would be amazing especially for Sawyer & Claire to see their loves

I would bring back Libby. For Hurley. I’d also like to find out why she was in the mental ward, but mostly for Hurley.

Juliet if she’s really gone. She is definitely worth saving. If she’s NOT gone, I’d have to save Eko.

Charlie for sure!

I would bring back Christian Shepard! Just imagine if the whole time Jack had gone to get his DRUNK Dad instead of his DEAD Dad.

DEFINITELY Charlie…hard to say why though.
could be the accent
or how he still makes me think of hobbits
or even his ability to balance being a fun and loveable good guy with an extreme darkside
or maybe it’s just the way he sings You All Everybody in that high falsetto
ha!

Bring back Mr. Ecko! He was a gentle giant of a badass.

probably Faraday
I would have liked to have his character explored more

I would save Juliet!

I would most definitely save Charlie! I loved his character’s transformation through the show and I cried when he died.

Faraday. I’ll never get enough Daniel Faraday.

Definitely Charlie, his redemption & transformation was the best. I was very sad to see him go.

Daniel Faraday. No one deserves to die, knowing their mother send them to their death.

JULIET!!! DEFINITELY!!!

Faraday for sure

Such a tough decision! I’d have to go with Juliet though. She’s the one whose story I most want to have continue.

If Juliet is actually dead, then without a doubt, her. Otherwise, I have to go with Charlie. Always loved him and was rather upset when he died.

I have to agree , Juliet. Her character is one of the more interesting, and her relationship with Sawyer has been too juicy to really end now.
I think the funly time travel will save her.

Juliet for sure. I’ve never really liked Kate but I always loved Sawyer. So when Juliet came onto the show I finally had a female character to root for to be with him.

Secondly would be Boone or Charlie. Massive love for both those sexy men

It’s a toss up between Charlie and Libby for me, but I guess I would chose Libby because we only got to see a really small part of her, and I loved her romance with Hurley!

CHARLIE!

Definitely Charlie!! Although, if Ian Somerhalder wasn’t currently rocking it on “The Vampire Diaries” I’d love to have Boone back too.

Faraday. I miss him then and I miss him now and I’ll miss him again.

I would save Juliet! The show will not be the same without her. I was hoping that she would make it alive until the series wrapped up.

Juliet – best female character on or off the island.

i would love to be boone back

It’s a toss up between Charlie and Juliet. Both had strong emotional deaths and would have an even stronger emotional rebirth if they were to be alive in the sixth season.

Juliet, hands down. That actress breathed supremacy whenever she spoke. Juliet was strong and vulnerable whenever the situation called for it. I was genuinely attached to her character… The way she was stuck on that island for so many years, it’ll be really great to see her reunite with her sister and her nephew in the alternate timeline, even if that meant losing her from the rest of the season…

Locke. Finding out it wasn’t really him the whole season was heartbreaking!

Faaaarrraaadaaayyyy

Oh Faraday. I will marry you, Daniel Faraday! If we bring him back, maybe we can figure out how to bring Locke back too! HOORAY!

charlie! oh god, makes me emotional just thinking about his goodbye.

Wow – to only pick just one…. but of all the characters I think I could narrow it down to:

Charlie – I loved this character – so flawed but had a good heart that eventually helped him redeem himself in the end.

Mr. Eko – I felt his story was cut horribly short – I loved his character and thought there was so much more to his story than we ever did see.

Faraday – I loved him – and other character that could probably give us so much more.

Libby – she was such a mystery and when I watch old episodes that she is in I find myself wanting to know what happened to her in her past.

Love this show!!

I’d probably go back and save Shannon. At the time I was fine with her being killed off but now I wish we had gotten a little bit more to do with her. Plus her final episode and her own flashback was great. I would love to see more of her.

Definitely Charlie….he kept me into the show. related to him.

Charlie because Hurley always seems so lost without him.

Charlie, for all the reasons Annabel mentioned.

Well, I’m in denial that Juliet is dead. I’m hoping she somehow survived. Hey, it’s the island! Anything can happen! If she is dead, then save Juliet. If she’s not, then I would save Charlie. I know his storyline was pretty played out, but I don’t care. I loved Charlie! And whatever happened to Claire?

I’d save Charlie. I don’t think I will ever get over his death, season’s later. He went through so much on and off the island; I just wanted him to get his happy ending. His death still provided on of the best lost scenes ever though. Penny coming over the comm. Writing his warning to Desmond on his hand. A-Mazing.

I’d save Charlie or Libby. I’m really interested in knowing what more is behind Libby’s character, but Charlie was just fun to have around. Curious that they were both close to Hurley…

Charlie. I still tear up when I think of his final redemptive death scene!

Rousseau — I would definitely enjoy knowing some more of her knowledge from all those years on that island!!

The character MICHAEL and the actor deserved a better storyline…and we needed more closure to WALT and his story…

Libby! the most abrupt end to a promising character ever, still so much of her story to explore.

I’d save Sun Kwon.

Boone!

Too pretty to die and I loved his snark.

BOOOOOOOOOOOOONE!

thanks for the contest = )

Shannon, she was hot

It’s a no-brainer, Charlie

Charlie!! I miss him.. Heroin addiction and all. “Track 1: Monster ate the pilot.”

Charlie, without a doubt. His death was very sad for the show, about the only one that really affected me. The show seems so incomplete without Charlie there to lighten the mood.

I vote for Mr. Eko. He went too soon.

Charley!

I’d have to go with Juliette

I, too, am going to have to go with Charlie. Although his death was both noble and heroic, it was one of the saddest moments (for me) in T.V. since the early cancellation of Veronica Mars. Without Charlie, it’s on the shoulders of Hurley and Sawyer to bring about some humor to the dismal lives of the Lost characters, and they’re all right, but without Charlie, something is definitely lacking…

I’m going to say Libby because there were so many unanswered questions with her.

Michael of course, he got the shaft during a shortened season

Charlie

cant wait for it to come back on. my fav is Ben. you never know what he will do nx

I would also say Locke. I feel that he was the driving force behind the show throughout its first five seasons, and went through the most compelling character ark on the show in season 2 with his rejection of destiny and faith.

I’m intrigued to see what Terry O’Quinn will do with his new character, but am sure that Locke will leave a void in the show.

LIBBY!

I’m dying to know what she was doing in the psych hospital with Hurley..
The girl had definite crazy eyes

Definitely got two: Mr. Eko and Charlie