Torn Between Two Realities: Is it wrong to love the alt-verse on FRINGE more than our universe?

At the end of Season 1 of FRINGE we were introduced to the alternate universe.  It is nearly an exact replica of the world we live in, with significant differences.  It is where the infamous William Bell had been hiding and where Peter Bishop originally hailed from until stolen by Walter when he was a boy.  With the revelation that FRINGE had actually taken us “over there,” it was a game-changer.  The mysteries that Fringe Division were encountering were no longer limited to earthly explanations – they could be explained by the fact that there was another doppelganger universe on the other side, from which people and objects were falling through the cracks.
Then at the end of Season 2, FRINGE dared to do the inconceivable and replaced Olivia Dunham with her doppelganger – leaving Olivia stranded on the other side and the faux-Olivia to wreck havoc in our world.  When it was first announced that the 3rd season episodes would flip-flop (one episode in our world, and the next in the alternate-verse), fans were dubious that the show would be able to pull off such a feat.  Would viewers and fans be able to watch a show that was essentially two shows in one with a tiny bridge in the temporal rift connecting them?

Yet as the third season debuted, the alt-verse was suddenly a lot more interesting and captivating than we expected.  Seeing Anna Torv playing the deliciously wicked Faux-Olivia and the confused Olivia who had been injected with memories of her doppelganger in order to pass her off as the alt-verse’s Olivia and so that she would agree to medical experimentation, was mind-blowing.  It became riveting to watch both what was going on in our verse with the Faux-Olivia and what was going on with Olivia in the alt-verse.  Instead of confusing viewers, it made the show even more compelling and gripping to watch.  The stakes were higher and the double-deception had us holding our breath in anticipation to see what small slip-ups would be revealed as Faux-Olivia knowingly tried to impersonate Olivia, and Olivia unknowingly was impersonating her alternate.  There were many clues to the switch, yet those closest to both did not spot the impersonations.  It meant that the viewers were virtually the only ones who knew and it was exciting being in on the secret.
So as each day loomed closer and closer to Olivia figuring out that the switch had been made and finding a way to return home, it began to dawn on me that I was going to be a bit heart-broken when she did.  In the space of eight episodes, they had accomplished the impossible – I did not want Olivia to return home.  I was going to miss the alt-verse too much – and it was not just the alt-verse, but rather how Olivia interacted with it. 
Watching Faux-Olivia back in her world was too mundane.  She was over-confident and predictable.  Plus, there was no danger.  Only when Olivia was in the alt-verse did it feel like it was filled with possibilities and mine-fields.  When would she figure out who she was?  Would anyone else notice before she did?  What small details would trip her up?  The same was true with Faux-Olivia in our world.  While she knew exactly who she was, her mission put her at odds with those around her.  She was a ruthless killer who would do anything to make sure her mission was not jeopardized.  As Olivia was picking up the pieces of her memories, Faux-Olivia was slowly destroying Olivia’s existence in our world.  It is unfortunate that the switch back was made so quickly as it was engrossing to see how each character was assimilating into the other’s life and changing it to suit their needs.
Olivia was perhaps changing the alter-verse Fringe Division to be a place where they were doing more good than they were harm.  Fringe Division is feared in the alt-verse.  They also seem a bit soul-less.  Olivia had brought her strengths of compassion, intuition and undeterred belief in the goodness of man balanced by her awareness of the evil of man too.  She was a strong asset for the alter-verse Fringe Division.
On the flip-side, Faux-Olivia was learning to be a better person while exposed to our world.  While in the end she did not deviate from her mission, she was touched and perhaps influenced by her time spent living in our world.  She began to see that we were not the enemy that she had been told all along.  She learned that Walter’s reasons for kidnapping Peter as a child was done out of love and that Peter willingly returned to our world because of his love for Olivia.  How can we be the heartless monsters as depicted by Alt-Walter when so many people’s motivations are derived from selfless love?  Yet even with this startling discovery, she ultimately chose to complete her mission and return home – without seeming to care about the chaos she had wrought, nor the destruction that she had unleashed by stealing a vital piece of “the machine.”  It remains to be seen if her experiences truly changed her or was it just a prick on her conscious that she chooses to ignore.
So as the remainder of the 3rd season of FRINGE returns on Friday, January 21st (with an episode entitled “Firefly” – talk about karmic irony!), it will be curious how quickly the show returns to the alt-verse.  Executive producers Jeff Pinker and J.H. Wyman have promised that the show will return to the alt-verse, but they have not said when or how frequently. 
With Peter and Olivia’s blossoming romance cut-short by the painful revelation that Peter could not see that Faux-Olivia was not his Olivia, the entire Fringe Division team in our world will be out of sorts.  Olivia feels heart-broken and betrayed that her life was invaded by a pretender who had so little regard for her privacy and personal relationships.  It has been agonizing to find out that no one missed her – no one noticed she was gone or realized that there was an imposter in their midst. 
In Olivia’s defense, she had been injected or programmed with Faux-Olivia’s memories and by doing so, it made her the perfect chameleon in the alt-verse.  She fit nearly seamlessly into Faux-Olivia’s life as a result.  But in the case of Faux-Olivia, she had not been programmed with Olivia’s memories and was merely playing a part.  She was merely pretending to be Olivia and did not actually believe she was Olivia. 
The symbiotic relationship and parallels illustrated by having the two Olivias live in each other’s lives was fascinating.  It added a level of danger, uncertainty and unpredictability to the series that kept us glue to our television sets.  It elevated “Fringe” from a monster/mystery-of-the-week format and dared to be a science fiction show breaking boundaries in sci-fi story-telling. 
Alas, all good things must come to an end.  It would have been wrong to leave Olivia in the alt-verse.  Or would it?  I know I am going to miss the mixed-up worlds and the challenging stories and character dilemmas that it inspired.  The story within a story format may have been taxing on fans who appreciate more linear or one-leveled story-telling, but for some of us, it was exhilarating.  
I remain torn between two worlds and two realities and find myself craving a world where Olivia lives in the alt-verse simply because it made some of the most compelling science fiction to ever grace the television screen.

FRINGE returns with brand new episodes Friday January 21, 2011

Tiffany Vogt is a contributing writer to TheTVAddict. She has a great love for television and firmly believes that entertainment is a world of wondrous adventures that deserves to be shared and explored – she invites you to join her. Please feel free to contact Tiffany at or follow her at on Twitter (@TVWatchtower).

For all the latest TV news and reviews

  • Nick

    I can’t speak for the alt-verse on Fringe, but I wouldn’t mind living in any of the various worlds on LOST.

  • Luis

    Same thing happened to me. I really enjoyed the flip between universes, but when watching alter-verse episodes I even thought about a spin-off centered in that world.

  • I sort of liken it to the final season of THE WEST WING, where I started feeling bad for enjoying the Matt Santos episodes far more than the President Bartlet ones!

  • Anonymous

    While I agree that the alternating episode format for the first half of this season was brilliant and certainly compelling, I’m glad they brought Olivia home when they did. I think it would have been a mistake for them to have tried to draw that story out too long. Too much of a good thing can turn bad.

  • Anonymous

    While I agree that the alternating episode format for the first half of this season was brilliant and certainly compelling, I’m glad they brought Olivia home when they did. I think it would have been a mistake for them to have tried to draw that story out too long. Too much of a good thing can turn bad.

  • I love the alt-verse, but love our characters more. I guess that’s the juxtaposition the writers are going for.

  • Bongomanhascome

    I’m with you Tiffany.

  • I like our universe much better. The alt-uni is more dictatorship run than not. But to be able to travel between both…that would be cool

  • Anonymous

    The blue universe is the best. We have coffee and avocados…..and Peter! All yummy!

  • Excellent article. Really picked up on the fact that Olivia living as Alternate Olivia was not her choice (obviously) and thus it’s not the same because she did not CHOOSE to do it but had it forced upon her. And THAT is why it is so hard to come back.
    If Otherlivia was made to believe she was Ourlivia, that would be a different thing. But that was obviously not an option because the whole point was she had to be the infiltrator with knowledge and orders from the other side for her mission. Deceive, inveigle, obfuscate. I cannot believe she can be so different from Ourlivia to not think there’s another way. (Both Ourlivia and Peter both believe there is and they do not want anyone to die in either universe. ) Otherlivia does seem to at least slightly acknowledge we’re not monsters but in the end, yes, she continues her mission anyway, where many lives are innocent lost. Is it out of fear of failure or just blind loyalty? Or both? Why does she still believe there can’t be another way. She not only lost my respect, but she lost her own dignity and self-respect when she chose to do this mission. She’s a pawn that needs to realize she’s being played. I want her to show guilt for what she’s done. Otherlivia: look at your life, look at your choices. She has severely exacerbated the war with her infiltration mission.
    Apart from that, I only enjoyed seeing the There eps mostly because it is good to see the differences, but on the whole, the reason I was loving them was Olivia. She’s my favorite character and I will love her until the day I die. I did adore seeing Lincoln being precious and Scarlie and Altstrid and Alt!Broyles. It was nice to see Kirk Acevedo back. Basically the people? I loved. The actual universe itself? Not so much. Besides, who want want to live in a world with no avocados and no pens?! AND ALSO NO COFFEE?! A world where wormholes pop up out of no where and suck you up, where oxygen just disappears randomly, where you could easily be encased in amber and live in a permanent state of stasis with the only thoughts running through your mind are the last seconds as you are being turned into the Mosquitos in Resin 2.0™ And it has Walternate as your egomaniacal Secretary of Defense? What a world.

    I’m excited for Fringe Fridays. All the alliteration. Fox. Fringe. Fridays. Freaky. Fantastic. Fun. Forever. Fan…

  • Deyon

    I love OUR Universe BETTER…show wasn’t as good to me when they put in the alt-verse. I missed seeing Walt and how funny he is with his son Peter…love that relationship. Walt makes the show, love his personality! Walt in the alt-verse is not funny but mean. That’s just my opinion.

  • Tau

    I agree with everything you just said! Viva la Fringe!!

  • Sneezewhiz

    Ooh, Olivia has an evil twin. I think “All My Children” had that idea about 20 years ago.
    Alternate world has zeppelins, authoritarian government and wants to destroy our world. Yeah, I think they’re cool.
    I do like the names they use: Walternate and Bolivia. Hah.

  • Joe Solo

    Alt-verse Rocks!

  • Fringe is such a well-written, well-casted program. The actors are what make Fringe believable and as to the realities of both universes, whether one deserves to survive at the other’s peril… it’s not even a toss-up… neither one can survive without the other. Now isn’t that the truth of the entire matter? You sense an urgent need on both sides.

  • Travelightly

    Hmmm, I didn’t like the alt universe. It was a meaner place. Olivia made it better. I did enjoy the relationship Olivia had with the cab driver and alt Broyles, though.

  • Dania

    I love the alt-verse, but it’s missing one very VERY key part, and I really miss it when it’s not there. Our Walter! While Walternate is deliciously, ambiguously evil (in a very Cigarette Smoking Man type of way), nothing compares to the brilliance of John Noble’s Walter in our world.

  • Lvialkash

    Just only the universe where Walter lives..

  • switbo

    Astrid and Broyles’ names weren’t even in the article – so where was the “hate”?? They only reference Walter’s reason for kidnapping Peter as being “out of love” and talk about his “selfless love” for Peter – so where was the “hate”. What article did you read?