Review: BODY OF PROOF (Alternate Title: How not to produce a procedural)

It takes a special type of procedural to entice us to tune into a show that we’d otherwise ignore. Unfortunately for BODY OF PROOF, ABC’s latest entrant into an already overcrowded marketplace, the only thing special about it is the astounding amount of disdain it seems to have for its audience.

From its overtly formulaic write-by-numbers nature, to its insistence on beating you over the head with its premise, BODY OF PROOF just about encapsulates everything that is wrong with the way modern day network television works. Almost to the point where we encourage you to watch tonight’s premiere in order to see just how little ABC respects its audience’s intelligence. But before we get into examining everything that is truly wrong with this show, let’s start with what is right.

Dana Delany is proof positive that unless your name is Meryl Streep, television is where it’s at for woman of a certain age. As Dr. Megan Hunt, a brilliant yet cantankerous Brain Surgeon who is forced to work as a Medical Examiner [ME] following a horrific car crash that leaves her incapable of operating, Delany single-handedly steals the show. Smart, sexy, hard-nosed yet vulnerable, it’s little mystery as to how the small screen staple has managed to carve out a career for herself that has lasted the better part of three decades.

Also solid are Delany’s supporting cast including partner Peter (Obligatory future love interest played by yet another Aussie import Nicholas Bishop), skeptical old school police detective (John Carroll Lynch) and her beautiful bombshell of a boss (the always welcome former numerical hottie Jeri “Seven of Nine” Ryan). Unfortunately where things get ugly are when the character’s start to open their mouths. And therein lies the problem.

It’s one thing to properly communicate the premise of a show (Read: Dr. Hunt, brilliant, hard to work with, pretty much the female equivalent of Dr. House or the Mentalist), it is another thing entirely to repeat said premise over and over and over again. Not only does every single scene feel the need to inexplicably reiterate Dr. Hunt’s current predicament (Again: She misses her previous life as a surgeon, regrets how her workaholic ways damaged her relationship with her 12-year old daughter who is currently residing with her bitter ex-husband who has sole custody and most importantly of all… plays by her on rules!) it does so with the clunkiest of clunky dialogue. So much so that after 44 minutes of enduring one-liners like “She [Megan] seems to care about dead people more than she ever cared about the living,” “I know a lot of ME’s [Medical Examiners] and none of them are a big as a pain in the ass as you are,” and “You might try playing nice once in a while.” we can pretty much guarantee that you’ll be yelling to your TV… WE GET IT!

Suffice to say, TV audiences deserve better, and so to does star Dana Delany. Grade: D

BODY OF PROOF premieres Tuesday May 29th at 10PM on ABC (CityTV in Canada)

For all the latest TV news and reviews

  • Anonymous

    This makes me sad….I was so looking forward to this as a big fan of Quincy and admirer of Dana Delaney.

  • Lunarhunter

    I’m still going to see it.Sometimes reviewers are tight ass snobs

  • Sincerely look forward to everybody checking it out and sharing your take.

  • Kelly

    I will still check it out, of course, but I really was not super excited about YET another procedural…are there no new ideas on TV anymore?

  • I’m disappointed. Of course I’ll be watching it for myself, but am I the only one thinking what the f$ck is ABC thinking this year?
    There development slate has been so poor and mediocre.
    From NOF, Mr.Sunshine, Better With You and Off The Map. None of these shows are outstanding or groundbreaking. Calling them mediocre would be a compliment.

    Body of Proof was pushed back, and was originally supposed to air in the fall. So you would think they would have really re-tooled it and made it great given so much extra time.

  • From the reviews I’ve read–some negative, some positive–it seems that most people’s reactions to this show hinges on how much you like Dana Delaney.

    I probably won’t watch this tonight but I’ll likely check it out later when there’s nothing else on. I like Dana Delaney and Sonja Sohn but not enough to forego my usual Lights Out/Parenthood/The Good Wife viewing.