Direct from the pages of our brand new, just released, first annual, Fall TV Preview eBook appropriately titled “Thank Goodness It’s Fall” comes a closer look at NBC’s latest attempt to rekindle that ER magic with CHICAGO FIRE.

Premieres: Wednesday, October 10 at 10 p.m. on CBS (Global in Canada).
In A Nutshell: Executive producer Dick Wolf — he of LAW & ORDER fame — takes a shot at the territory trod by shows like EMERGENCY and RESCUE ME.
Names You’ll Know: Taylor Kinney (THE VAMPIRE DIARIES), David Eigenberg (SEX & THE CITY), Lauren German (HAWAII FIVE-0), Merle Dandridge (SONS OF ANARCHY) and Jesse Spencer (HOUSE M.D.) are just some of the familiar faces populating Chicago Firehouse 51.
What They Say: “This is not fire of the week,” swears Wolf. “It’s a character study about people who do jobs you can’t pay people to do.”
What Others Say: The Huffington Post’s Laura Prudom writes that it “boasts a great cast, but they’re all too busy talking in leaden, clichéd Procedural Speak, so there’s no joy, humor or personality. Based on the pilot, I’d say skip it, but I want to give it another episode in the hope it loosens up.”
What We Say: Maybe if it actually were a fire-of-the-week show, there’d be more intensity to it. As it is, we have a good cast basically going through the motions. We meet a lot of people very quickly, and unless you happen to recognize them from a previous role (it’s easy to spot Kinney, as he’s the one stripped down regularly), the faces, names and personal traumas can sort of blend together. There may be a good show in here somewhere, but right now, it’s all smoke, no fire.

For more great reviews, exclusive interviews with some of your favorite showrunners and actors, as well as printable calendars and Emmy ballots, please consider supporting theTVaddict.com by checking out our First Annual Fall TV Preview eBook.>>

For all the latest TV news and reviews